Acessibilidade / Reportar erro

Morality and Homicide among Young Killers1 1 This paper is a product of the research project Situation and Significance of Violent Juvenile Behavior carried out with support from the Open Society Foundations, Grant OR2015-22505. Albany Sánchez assisted in the interviews with records and transcripts. Staff from Servicio de Protección Integral de Niños, Niñas y Adolescentes del Estado Miranda (Sepinami) y and from Detention Center of Vargas State Police, at Caraballeda, Venezuela, granted access to interviewees. I am grateful for institutional support from Directorate for Protection of Family from the General Attorney’s Office in Venezuela, and to Philip Stenning and Eduardo Paes Machado for comments on an earlier draft. Thanks to Mary Bratt for her accurate revision of the English text.

Moralidade e homicídio entre jovens assassinos

ABSTRACT

Morality among juveniles convicted of homicide is approached through balance or polarity, while self-empowerment becomes central for accounts. Feelings are analyzed as a source of plausible grounds for acting, though not necessarily suited to or legitimate according to a conventional code of behavior. Fear, in a sense of despair and menace, and rage, connected to power and excitement, were recurrent. Perceptions of self-enhancement and polarity rather than balance, without belittling the victim or presenting her as disreputable, marked a trend. Punishment was often linked to deprivation of contacts with family, suggesting social relevance of relatives, particularly women, in killings and accounts. A novel approach is suggested for assessing moral claims in homicides by juveniles, addressed to alternative audiences beyond the criminal justice system.

Keywords:
violence; accounts; juveniles; narratives; self-presentation

Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro Largo de São Francisco de Paula, 1, Sala 109, Cep: 20051-070, Rio de Janeiro - RJ / Brasil , (+55) (21) 3559.1926 - Rio de Janeiro - RJ - Brazil
E-mail: coordenacao.dilemas@gmail.com