Health expectancy indicators: what do they measure?

Indicadores de expectativa de vida saudável: o que medem?

Abstract

Background

Health expectancy indicators aim at capturing the quality dimension of total life expectancy.; however, the underlying approach, definition of health, and information source differ considerably among the indicators available.

Objective

(1) Review the main concepts and approaches used to estimate health expectancy focusing on two widely used European health indicators: Health-Adjusted Life Expectancy (HALE) and Healthy Life Years (HLY); (2) identify underlying differences between the results yielded by these two indicators.

Method

Statistical differences between the HALE and HLY indicators by sex at ages 50, 60, and 70 were tested using pairwise and global Student´s t-tests and z-scores based on standard deviation. Data for 29 European countries were collected from the European Health Expectancy Monitoring Unit (EHEMU) information system and the World Health Organization (WHO) Global Burden of Disease Study 2016 (GBD 2016).

Results

The HALE indicator estimates were smoother across European countries compared with those of the HLY indicator, present a narrower sex gap in morbidity, higher z-scores compared with the average distribution across Europe, and results less sensitive to cross-national variations.

Conclusion

The HALE estimates indicate that morbidity is more compressed for both sexes, whereas the HLY estimates suggest that morbidity is more compressed for males but more expanded for females. These contrasting results demonstrate that health expectancy indicators should be interpreted with caution.

Keywords:
HALE; HLY; Sullivan’s method; health expectancy; morbidity